Are Women Better Doctors?

by in American Sickcare System, Diet Tips, Kitchen Sink, Reader Questions May 11, 2008

womendoctor1.jpg Seventy years ago the only doctors in America were men.

My 98 year old grandma was a RN back in the day, and I am always fascinated by her stories of how different and barbaric medicine was not too long ago.

When I asked what made her choose to be a nurse she simply responded, “Women were only allowed to go to school to be nurses or teachers. So I just chose to be a nurse.”

I would be a nurse right now too, that is if a bunch of women hadn’t stood up for what they thought was right and fought for equal opportunity.

Even as a three year old girl my mom knew I would go in to the medical field. I remember my grandpa’s friends leaning in and asking “So what do you want to be when you grow up, dear?”

“A doctor” I would simply answer.

“You mean a nurse, honey?”
They would smile in amusement.

“No, a doctor” I would confidently reply, naive to the fact that being a doctor wasn’t a thing a girl grew up to do in their paradigm.

Much has changed over the course of the last few decades and now we are fortunate enough to have equal opportunity. That is with many thanks to the women that fought for equal rights. In 1961 only 5.5% of students in medical programs were women. In the past 47 years we have made some real progress as 48.6% of students matriculated in medical school programs are now female.

Many people, male and female, don’t always enjoy being a doctor because it is a tremendous never ending responsibility. Anyone in an information based profession knows full well what a nightmare certain social events can be when people are asking for free advice. It is only when you are sick, exhausted, and having the worst day ever, that you are held hostage by some long lost family member or remote friend of a friend that wants to drill you for information.

When I find myself caught in those annoying moments I dig deep for gratitude. Gratitude that I am fortunate enough to even be a doctor. To have had a lifelong dream, and have been able to follow it. Mere decades ago I could have had the dream but never had the opportunity to fulfill it. I often remind myself of all the women that wanted to be doctors and were never allowed to actualize their dreams, so that I can muster the needed enthusiasm to care for an acquaintance’s non-urgent medical problems in my free time.

In naturopathic medical school about 75% of the students matriculated are women. The nature of our medicine tends to attract female students as well as female patients, as I would guess that 75% of my patients are also female. When I worked at Virginia Mason Medical Center it seemed that the female general practitioners were always in hot demand. It appeared that most women only wanted to see women physicians and many men also felt more comfortable being examined by a female doctor. Most women were willing to wait a week for an appointment regarding an acute complaint, and 3 months for an appointment with a female practitioner just for an annual physical! Over the eight years that I worked there, the clinic was finally forced to keep up with patient demands and hire on more and more female providers.

From my observations though, the clinic would have had to have a staff of female providers well above 50% in order to satisfy patient demand. Women tend to go to the doctor more frequently than men, so it only makes sense that the clinic continues to hire on female doctors until they reach their saturation point with patient satisfaction. Especially since most of the demand for female practitioners was coming from the younger generations, the demand should only continue to grow.

Which got me thinking…is having a staff of female physicians greater than 50% going against the rights of male physicians? Should medical schools then matriculate more women to satisfy demands in out-patient care, or is that just oppressive to males? What do you think? Do you insist on a female doctor, or do you have no preference?

Researchers at John Hopkins concluded after a large meta-analysis that women doctors spent more time with their patients (an average of 23 minutes vs 21 minutes), that they established better emotional rapport, talked to them more, and involved the patient more in the treatment plan.

Personally I have seen some very amazing male physicians in action so I have a hard time arguing that women are better doctors, I think it all depends on the individual. But, I do have to say that the results of that study involving 900 physicians and 3700 patients should make a lot of women proud!

Whether you are a female physician, or any woman that has a job that you love, if you are making a fair wage, if you are educated, you owe thanks to all the women that fought for you. Just stop and ask an older woman what it was like back in the fifties, sixties, seventies and even eighties for women in the work world, you will be surprised to hear about things that were going on not too long ago. If you care to comment on what life was like for you working in an extremely unequal work force, I would love to hear from you!

Also in honor off Mother’s Day don’t forget to tell your mom thank you for driving you around in all the carpools, packing all those lunches, helping you with your homework, dealing with you when you were tediously annoying, doing a million thoughtful labors of love that often go unnoticed and without credit, as well as all the other sacrifices that each mother has to make for the sake of the greater good. And all in the name of putting quality people out there in this world.

mothersday.jpgI would like to extend a heartfelt thank you to my Mom and all of you “Mothers” in my life.

Thank you all for what you have done, for what you do, and for what you continue to do!

Thank you especially to all the women older than me (21 and above of course) that fought to make our work environment what it is today.

Things may still not quite be perfect, but they certainly are a whole lot better.

Happy Mother’s Day!!!

~Dr. Nicole

17 Comments
  1. Good post! Nice to see your smiling face again! – Nards

  2. I have never really thought about the difference. Honestly – I usually will go to the Dr. Best suited for the issue at hand. Never once giving the sex of the Dr a thought…

    Ben

  3. A great tribute to women in general and women in medicine! And just in time for Mother’s Day!

    It’s so crazy to me how things were indeed to barbaric way back when. I can only be incredibly grateful for the decade in which I was born. Today women can do and be almost anything they want to be. No one EVER questioned my decision to become a doctor!

    That’s the way it should have always been. How, back then did a person with a uterus make her THAT different from a man? My belief is simple. The power of the muscle (strength), not wisdom is how it all began.

    Dr. KC
    http://www.DOCintheBiz.com

  4. Erin Happycamper May 12, 2008 at 12:04 pm Reply

    Love ya doc!!!! =x

  5. I just figured out how to comment here. *caveman*

    I have been reading, but now that I can comment I just want to let you know that I really enjoy your articles/blogs.

    I think you are doing a great job here!

  6. Hi Nards! Thanks 😀

  7. Hi Benny- Good to know! I think more men are flexible about the kind of Dr. they have then women…for the most part.

  8. Hi Dr. KC! That was a great post you wrote today at http://docinthebiz.com/blog on holding all our relationships together, and although it is much needed today, sadly enough fifty years ago would have been relatively irrelevant as women didn’t have all the options to wear all those hats!

  9. Hi Erin! Love you too dear! Thanks for stopping by 😀

  10. Hi JC! Yay you finally made a comment! Hooray.

    You see everyone…if a caveman can do it…then anyone can do it!

    Really. I promise!

    All you do is type your message in the box, add your name and email and voila! Your opinion has been heard by the cybermasses!!!

    HOORAY!!!

  11. Women, of course, can be better doctors when they minus out the extra emotions they show.

  12. I don’t think sex of the Doctor plays anything at all into their abilities as a physician expect maybe when it comes to beside manner.

  13. TerryFalconhawke May 17, 2008 at 7:55 pm Reply

    Doc I have a couple of things to share. My wife gave birth to my daughter on mother’s day. This year is one of those years that daughter birthday and mothers day fall on the same day. Also I had a good friend whom is long passed Mrs. Kopecky a descendant of Ben Franklin. Her and her husband met at medical school. After graduation she kept her certification yet never practiced. She did the old house wife thing. She would go to siminars and conventions with her husband. It thought it odd to work so hard for something and not do it. Yet she was a very happy lady. I guess that’s all that matters…..Terry

  14. Not sure if it is subconscious or not, but my belief is that a man doctor will take better care of a woman patient and a woman doctor will take better care of a man patient . I always pick a female doctor, if I have a choice.

    Pol’s last blog post..How to Eat Healthy While Traveling

  15. You needn’t worry about discrimination against male doctors – for years it was all their way – they could always see a male Dr, while women had no choice…the result – a long and well documented history of disrespect, abuse of trust and blatant sexual assault by male doctors against their female Dr’s…..
    Hardly surprising that many women feel more comfortable with a female Dr (regardless of the history)….no man can understand just how vulnerable and powerless a woman may feel during a a pelvic exam – let alone being performed by a male doctor….
    I’m so grateful I have a choice….thank you for choosing medical school.
    Just as men always have the choice of a male urologist, we now have a choice….and some don’t like it – well IMO, that’s just too bad…
    It is our right to see the Dr of our choosing….
    As a young lawyer, I worked at the Medical Board and was left shocked and appalled….
    I lost trust forever….
    Women were once ridiculed if they preferred to see a female Dr – that has changed – NEVER see a male Dr unless it’s YOUR choice.
    It’s clear some women suffer trauma and distress when a male Dr is forced on them – particularly for an invasive exam. Don’t allow anyone to dismiss or ignore your request…stand up for yourselves – the Dr-patient dynamic makes it difficult for many women to speak up or end an exam….
    Congratulations Dr – thanks for adding to our very valuable pool of female doctors.

  16. the 5th line should read “against their female patients”…
    I’m sure you worked it out…..

  17. Ed Smith, Palm Springs, CA May 10, 2009 at 3:17 pm Reply

    While I certainly agree that females should have an equal shot at any job males do, most people are completely naive regarding the true motivation behind the number one force behind the women’s liberation movement, the Rockefellers. The Rockefellers wanted women to be able to work in order to be able to TAX the other half of the population, and also so that more children would be attending public schools, with more of their thinking being molded by the government instead of by the parents in home schooling. They did not care about working for women’s equality. Sad but true.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *